2008 Pittsburgh LGBT Film Festival
--Winner, Audience Favorite, "Kinsey Sicks: Almost Infamous"

2008 Independent Reviewers of New England (IRNE) Nomination
--Best Visiting Production (Wake the F@#k Up America)

2008 MAC Award (Manhattan Association of Clubs & Cabarets) Nomination
--Best Comedy/Improv Group

2008 Nightlife Award Nomination (New York City)
-- Outstanding Comic Group

2005 OUTmusic Award Nominations
-- Out Musician of the Year
-- Best Musical Group
-- Best Producer (I Wanna Be a Republican)

2003 San Francisco Bay Guardian Readers' Poll
-- Winners, Best of the Bay

2003 OUTmusic Award Nomination
-- Out Musician of the Year

2002 Contemporary A Cappella Recording Awards Nomination
-- Artist of the Year

2001 Drama Desk Award Nomination, Ben Schatz
-- Outstanding Lyrics for "Dragapella! Starring the Kinsey Sicks"

2001 Lortel Award Nominations
-- Best Musical and Best Costumes for "Dragapella! Starring the Kinsey Sicks"

2001 GLAAD Media Award Nomination
-- for "Dragapella! Starring the Kinsey Sicks"

2000 Contemporary A Cappella Recording Awards
-- Comedy Category

1999 West Coast Harmony Sweepstakes
-- Winners, Audience Favorite
-- Winners, Best Song